Tuesday, 10 January 2017

Malaysia-Press Release | Freedom of Speech and Expression Must be Resolutely Protected

Press Release | Freedom of Speech and Expression Must be Resolutely Protected






​__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Press Release
Freedom of Speech and Expression Must be Resolutely Protected
The Malaysian Bar welcomes the two recent landmark decisions of the Court of Appeal that have dealt a critical blow to the Sedition Act 1948.

In the case of Mat Shuhaimi bin Shafiei v Kerajaan Malaysia, section 3(3) of the Sedition Act 1948 — which provides that the intention of the accused is irrelevant to a sedition charge — was struck down as invalid, as it is a disproportionate restriction on the freedom of speech for the purposes of Article 10(2) of the Federal Constitution, and in breach of the guarantee of equal treatment and equal protection before the law under Article 8 of the Federal Constitution.

In delivering the unanimous decision of the Court of Appeal, Justice Varghese George accepted the submission that "… section 3 (3) of [the Sedition Act 1948] was an overkill, akin to using 'a hammer to confront the menace of a mosquito'".

Justice George further added: "It was indisputable that an accused [charged with an offence under section 4 (read together with section 3(1)) of the Sedition Act 1948] would be clearly disadvantaged and in effect discriminated.  This in effect would leave open the door for selective prosecution, an anathema or affront to the constitutional right to be dealt with equally and to be also protected equally before the law."

In the case of Muhammad Safwan Bin Anang @ Talib v Pendakwaraya, the Court of Appeal acquitted and discharged Muhammad Safwan, who had been charged under section 4(1) of the Sedition Act 1948.
Justice Prasad Sandosham Abraham, in delivering the unanimous decision, suggested that the courts should take the "tooth comb" approach in deciding whether the impugned words have "a seditious tendency".  Justice Abraham further said, inter alia, that "…the Court must scrutinize and independently evaluate the impugned statement to see whether the language used comes within the bounds of sedition rather than free speech; and failure to do so, by the Court in our view amounts to a serious misdirection in law which would render a conviction unsafe".
These landmark decisions are indeed laudable, and are a strong endorsement for the freedom of speech and expression.
The Malaysian Bar notes that, in stark contrast, the authorities frequently used the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998 ("CMA") in 2016 to suppress contrary views, muzzle press freedom, and deny democratic space.

Section 233(1)(a) of the CMA criminalises, among others, the use of network facilities or network services by a person to transmit any communication that is deemed to be offensive and could cause annoyance to another person.  It is broad in scope, vague and ambiguous, with entirely subjective terms such as "offensive" and "annoy", and has been used to quash contrary or dissenting voices in the public sphere.

In 2016 alone, the number of reported cases totalled at least 39, including persons questioned, arrested, charged or sentenced.  Such resort to the CMA by the authorities has a chilling effect on the freedom of opinion and thought, and creates a climate of fear that suffocates freedom of expression and threatens to silence Malaysians.  Its use to stifle all forms of dissent continued unabated into the new year, as it was reported on 7 January 2017 that a man in Dungun, Terengganu had been arrested for allegedly criticising the Prime Minister.   
Another provision of the CMA that has been abused is section 263(2), which provides for the barring of public access to websites.  This has been perceived as intimidation and harassment of the media.

The continuing misuse of sections 233(1)(a) and 263(2) of the CMA is a serious encroachment on the freedom of speech and expression guaranteed under Article 10(1)(a) of the Federal Constitution and, more critically, the freedom of opinion and thought.  The freedom of the press is integral to the freedom of speech and expression, and is regarded as a necessary derivative of the right to know.  The right to know, or the right to information, is also implicit in this constitutional guarantee, and belongs to every citizen.

While it is recognised that the freedom of expression is not absolute, any restriction of this fundamental liberty must be reasonable and proportionate, and cannot be founded on any arbitrary or unlawful exercise of power by the authorities.  This would be nothing less than a frontal assault on the rule of law, and would render the constitutional guarantee in Article 10(1)(a) meaningless.

The Sedition Act 1948 remains a serious threat to the freedom of speech and expression, while the misuse of sections 233(1)(a) and 263(2) of the CMA gives rise to the perception that the CMA is yet another dressed-up political weapon.

The Malaysian Bar calls upon the Government to cease its use of, and to repeal, these legislation that negate the exercise of the freedoms of speech, expression, opinion and thought, which are guaranteed in the Federal Constitution to all citizens. 

George Varughese
Vice-President
Malaysian Bar

9 January 2017



LexisNexis: Must Have Titles Part I [ Collector's Item, Administrative Law, Banking & Finance, Bankruptcy, Business Law, Intellectual Property, Land Law, Personal Injury, Tax Law & Employment Law ]

Must Have Titles Part I [ Collector's Item, Administrative Law, Banking & Finance, Bankruptcy, Business Law, Intellectual Property, Land Law, Personal Injury, Tax Law & Employment Law ]



Collector's Item

Malayan Cases


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : MLJ
No of Pages : 4 Volumes
Edition : First Edition
Published Date : 2015
Print: RM777.00



Administrative Law

MP Jain's Administrative Law of Malaysia and Singapore


Author : Dr Damien J. Cremean
No of Pages : 928
Edition : Fourth Edition
Published Date : 2011
Print / eBook: RM300.00
Print + eBook: RM390.00



Banking & Finance

Banking Law


Author : Lee Mei Pheng, Detta Samen & Ivan Jeron Detta
No of Pages : 1292
Edition : Fourth Edition
Published Date : 2012
Print / eBook: RM450.00
Print + eBook: RM585.00



Bankruptcy

LexisNexis Annotated Statute Series: Bankruptcy


Author : LexisNexis
No of Pages : 458
Published Date : 2013
Print / eBook: RM80.00
Print + eBook: RM104.00



Business Law

Business Law in Malaysia


Author : Dr. Krishnan Arjunan & Dr. Abdul Majid bin Nabi Baksh
No of Pages : 992
Edition : Second Edition
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM180.00
Print + eBook: RM234.00



Islamic Business


General Editors : Jothee Sinnakkannu, Mahendhiran Nair, Grace H.Y. Lee
No of Pages : 312
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM120.00
Print + eBook: RM156.00



Intellectual Property

Compendium of Malaysian Intellectual Property Cases – Trade Marks Volume 1


Author : Foong Cheng Leong
No of Pages : 1024
Edition :Second Edition
Published Date : 2013
Print / eBook: RM150.00
Print + eBook: RM195.00



Compendium of Malaysian Intellectual Property Cases – Copyright and Industrial Designs Volume 2


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : Foong Cheng Leong
Print: RM275.00
eBook: RM291.50



Understanding Personal Data Protection Law


Author : Noriswadi Ismail
No of Pages : 212
Published Date : 2013
Print / eBook: RM150.00
Print + eBook: RM195.00




Land Law

Land Law in Malaysia Cases and Commentary


Author : Professor Teo Keang Sood & Datuk Dr. Khaw Lake Tee
No of Pages : 1608
Edition :Third Edition
Published Date : 2012
Print / eBook: RM350.00
Print + eBook: RM455.00



Sarawak Land Code Chapter 81 (1958 Edition)


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author :LexisNexis
No of Pages : 200
Edition :Third Edition
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM60.00
Print + eBook: RM78.00



Sabah Land Ordinance (Cap 68)


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : LexisNexis
No of Pages : 160
Edition : Second Edition
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM70.00
Print + eBook: RM91.00



Sarawak Land Code (with Annotations)


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author :LexisNexis
No of Pages : 200
Edition : Third Edition
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM250.00
Print + eBook: RM325.00



Principles of Malaysian Land Law


Author : Ainul Jaria Maidin, Azlinor Sufian, Bashiran Begum, Fauziah Md Noor, Nor Asiah Mohamad, Ratna Azah binti Rosli, Sharifah Zubaidah Syed Abdul Kader
No of Pages : 745
Published Date : 2008
Print / eBook: RM130.00
Print + eBook: RM169.00



Conveyancing Practice and Procedure in West Malaysia


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author :LexisNexis
No of Pages : 200
Edition : Second Edition
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM220.00
Print + eBook: RM286.00



Medical and Personal Injury Law

Personal Injury: Quantum, Cases and Materials Volume 3 (Supplement)


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : LexisNexis
No of Pages : 522
Edition : Third Edition
Published Date : 2013
Print / eBook: RM200.00
Print + eBook: RM260.00



Tax Law

Malaysian Revenue Law Case Digest


Author : Choong Kwai Fatt
No of Pages : 580
Published Date : 2013
Print / eBook: RM220.00
Print + eBook: RM286.00



GST 360 A Comprehensive Compendium


Author : LexisNexis
No of Pages : 1236
Published Date : 2015
Print / eBook: RM185.00
Print + eBook: RM240.50



Principles of Double Taxation (Relief) Agreements


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : Dr. Arjunan Subramaniam
No of Pages : 160
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM230.00
Print + eBook: RM299.00



Understanding GST


Author : Dr. Arjunan Subramaniam
No of Pages : 200
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM120.00
Print + eBook: RM156.00



Revenue Law in Singapore and Malaysia


Author : Senior Professor Dr Leo Desmond Pointon, Jeong Chun Phuoc
No of Pages : 806
Edition : Third Edition
Published Date : 2012
Print / eBook: RM260.00
Print + eBook: RM338.00



Employment Law

Procedure for Unfair Dismissal Claims in Malaysia


Author : Ashgar Ali Ali Mohamed & Farheen Baig Sardar Baig
No of Pages : 616
Published Date : 2009
Print / eBook: RM175.00
Print + eBook: RM227.50



Dismissal from Employment and the Remedies


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : Ashgar Ali Ali Mohamed
No of Pages : 944
Edition : Second Edition
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM250.00
Print + eBook: RM325.00



Employment Law in Malaysia


Author : Dr Sharifah Suhanah Syed Ahmad
No of Pages : 314
Published Date : 2012
Print / eBook: RM170.00
Print + eBook: RM221.00



For a purchase, do not hesitate to contact me,

Jamie Tang
Telesales Executive
LexisNexis Malaysia Sdn Bhd
T1-6,Jaya 33,
3,Jln Semangat,
Seksyen 13,
46100,Petaling Jaya,
Selangor Darul Ehsan




Please consider the environment before printing.


"My success can only follow your success."


LexisNexis: Must Have Titles Part II [ Construction Law, Company Law, Commercial Law, Civil Litigation, Contract Law, Family Law, Insurance, Criminal Litigation, & Evidence ]

LexisNexis: Must Have Titles Part II [ Construction Law, Company Law, Commercial Law, Civil Litigation, Contract Law, Family Law, Insurance, Criminal Litigation, & Evidence ]






Construction Law

The PAM 2006 Standard Form of Building Contract


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : Sundra Rajoo, Dato' W.S.W. Davidson, Ir. Harbans Singh K.S
No of Pages : 998
Published Date : 2010
Print / eBook: RM350.00
Print + eBook: RM455.00



Harbans' Engineering and Construction Contracts Management: Commencement & Administration


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : Ir Harbans Singh KS
No of Pages : 1104
Edition : Second Edition
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM250.00
Print + eBook: RM325.00



Harbans' Engineering and Construction Contracts Management: Pre-Contract Award Practice


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : Ir Harbans Singh KS
No of Pages : 698
Edition : Second Edition
Published Date : 2012
Print / eBook: RM180.00
Print + eBook: RM234.00



Company Law

Concise Principles of Company Law in Malaysia


Author : Shanthy Rachagan, Janine Pascoe, Anil Joshi
No of Pages :  692
Edition : Second Edition
Published Date : 2010
Print / eBook: RM150.00
Print + eBook: RM195.00



Mergers & Acquisitions in Malaysia


Author : Prof. Dr. Christopher Kummer, Dr. Franz Ferdinand Eiffe, Dr. Wolfgang Molzer, Andre Gan, Teo Ee Von
No of Pages : 176
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM150.00
Print + eBook: RM195.00



The Law on Shareholders' Meetings AGM and EGM


Author : Chen Thim Wai
No of Pages : 272
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM150.00
Print + eBook: RM195.00



Guide to Table A


Author : Chen Thim Wai
No of Pages : 348
Published Date : 2012
Print / eBook: RM150.00
Print + eBook: RM195.00



Commercial

Whistleblower Protection Law


Author : Leo Desmond Pointon & Jeong Chun Phuoc
No of Pages : 616
Published Date : 2012
Print / eBook: RM150.00
Print + eBook: RM195.00



Hire Purchase (Bilingual)


Author : Joshua Kevin
No of Pages : 326
Published Date : 2008
Print / eBook: RM150.00
Print + eBook: RM195.00



Civil Litigation

LexisNexis Civil Litigation Series Part 1-4


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : LexisNexis
No of Pages : 1000+
Published Date : 2013-2014
Print: RM1,234.00 (Promotion)



A Practical Guide of Specific Performance


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : Kanesh Sundram
No of Pages : 456
Published Date : 2013
Print / eBook: RM230.00
Print + eBook: RM299.00



Contract Law

Law of Contract


Author : Dato' Seri Dr Visu Sinnadurai
No of Pages : 2 Volumes
Edition : Fourth Edition
Published Date : 2011
Print / eBook: RM700.00
Print + eBook: RM910.00



Contracts Act: A Commentary


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : Tan Sri Dato' Seri Visu Sinnadurai
No of Pages : 1120
Published Date : 2015
Print / eBook: RM300.00
Print + eBook: RM390.00



The Law of Restitution and Unjust Enrichment in Malaysia


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : Low Weng Tchung
No of Pages : 270
Published Date : 2015
Print / eBook: RM250.00
Print + eBook: RM325.00



Principles of Law of Contract in Malaysia


Author : Dr Syed Ahmad Alsagoff
No of Pages : 864
Edition : Fourth Edition
Published Date : 2015
Print / eBook: RM150.00
Print + eBook: RM195.00



Family Law

Resolving Child Custody Disputes


Author : Dr Mehrun Siraj
No of Pages : 224
Published Date : 2012
Print / eBook: RM150.00
Print + eBook: RM195.00



Native Court and Customary Law of Sabah (with Cases and Decisions)


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : LexisNexis
No of Pages : 384
Edition : 2015 Edition
Published Date : 2015
Print / eBook: RM199.00
Print + eBook: RM258.70



Insurance

Law of Life Insurance


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : S Santhana Dass
No of Pages : 740
Edition : Second Edition
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM350.00
Print + eBook: RM455.00



Criminal Litigation & Evidence

Mallal's Criminal Procedure


No of Pages : 1318
Edition : Seventh Edition
Published Date : 2012
Print / eBook: RM550.00
Print + eBook: RM715.00



The Process of Criminal Justice, Part II


Author : Lee Chong Fook & Che Audah Hassan
No of Pages : 204
Edition : Second Edition
Published Date : 2014
Print / eBook: RM190.00
Print + eBook: RM247.00



Offences Against Persons and Property


Author : Lee Chong Fook, Che Audah Hassan
No of Pages : 296
Published Date : 2009
Print / eBook: RM130.00
Print + eBook: RM169.00



Legal Aspects of Money Laundering in Malaysia from the Common Law Perspective


Author : Lee Chong Fook, Che Audah Hassan
No of Pages : 296
Published Date : 2009
Print / eBook: RM160.00
Print + eBook: RM208.00



Evidence in Malaysia and Singapore: Cases, Materials and Commentary


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : Rafiah Salim & Cheong May Fong
No of Pages : 806
Edition : Third Edition
Published Date : 2013
Print / eBook: RM250.00
Print + eBook: RM325.00



Evidence: Practice and Procedure


Author : Augustine Paul
No of Pages : 1450
Edition : Fourth Edition
Published Date : 2010
Print / eBook: RM520.00
Print + eBook: RM676.00



Law of Evidence in Malaysia


See brochure in the attached for more info.

Author : Mariette Peters
No of Pages : 528
Published Date : 2013
Print / eBook: RM130.00
Print + eBook: RM169.00



For a purchase, do not hesitate to contact me,

Jamie Tang
Telesales Executive
LexisNexis Malaysia Sdn Bhd
T1-6,Jaya 33,
3,Jln Semangat,
Seksyen 13,
46100,Petaling Jaya,
Selangor Darul Ehsan




Please consider the environment before printing.


"My success can only follow your success."

Proview eBook Bi-Weekly Offer - Get your copy at 20% off!

Proview eBook Bi-Weekly Offer - Get your copy at 20% off! ...